Voice is a slippery thing. Trying to grab hold of it is often as easy as capturing a bit of fog in your hand. And even when you've found your voice, you're not quite sure what it is. You only know that something feels different. Your friends are commenting that they see it in your writing. You think to yourself, "What am I doing different?" and more importantly, "Can I do it again?"
I blame a writer's struggle with voice on teachers. (Sorry. Ouch. I know. I am one. But hey, I teach math. What harm could I do? Yeah, right. I know.) Hmmm...was that voice? But, as usual, I digress. Many writers look back upon their school days and remember those early attempts at writing. I have some particularly awful poems and even a screen play that I wrote. (The screen play, I've decided, was possibly a direct result of reading Freckle Juice by
Judy Blume.) Since her book is not written as a screen play, I don't think I can be accused of plagiarism. At least, I hope not. Since it will never see the light of day beyond my own home, I don't think I'll need to worry about it. (Yes, I still have it, complete with a construction paper cover crudely illustrated by...myself.)
But my favorite was a story I wrote about a white horse named, (of course), Snow Queen. I was the protagonist, I rode around on this beautiful steed, attired in fringe buckskin, catching all the criminals. I was soooo famous, I never even had to do the paperwork. That chore was assigned to the underlings in the police department.
Of course, I thought this story was amazing. Imagine my devastation when I got it back with red marks all over it. I don't even remember the grade. Just the red. I remember whining to my mom that they didn't even comment on the creativity. (I don't think I still have this story. One day, I'll have to look for it. It would make a wonderful slide on an author presentation, don't you think? Along with the cover of
Freddy the Frog with Freckles?
But the main thing I remember, (yes, I remember, I'm supposed to be talking about voice here), was how often I was told, "You write like you talk." Like that was a bad thing? And not just that one 6th grade teacher. (Robin Hill. Creve Coeur, Missouri. You know who you are.) But all the way through. I teach with an incredible language arts teacher now. I had her in high school. Sorry to say, I don't actually remember her as a teacher, which is totally weird, because she's really, really good, but I do still have scads of writing from her class. With the red pen. Lots of it.
"Don't write like you talk."
But as an avid reader, here's what I'm coming to realize. Maybe voice
is writing like you talk. I recently reviewed
Headlock by
Joyce Sweeney. I know Joyce well enough that I know the rhythm of her speech. Her voice. And as I read her book, I
heard her voice. In my head, I could hear her saying certain phrases. It
sounded like her.
Same thing with
Prom Kings and Drama Queens by
Dorian Cirrone. Dorian was the first one to critique one of my YA manuscripts. I've known her long enough that as I read her book, again, I could hear her voice. Her witty sarcasm.
And writer buddies,
Linda Eadie,
Paul May, and
Ena Jones. Remember those names, you'll want to pick up their books one day. After years of working together to perfect our craft, I know their voices. I know them so well that if I were to pick up one of their manuscripts, without knowing they were the author, I'd know they'd written it. I can
hear their voice.
Did any of you used to listen in the the voices of brothers
John Green and
Hank Green, on their
video blog? Listen to the way John talks. Hear how he ends his statements with a question mark? And listen to his language. "Hyper-physical medium called real life?" Who talks like that? (Amazing, isn't he.) Now go read his books. Same voice. Same language. Same wry wit. Same nerdiness.
That's voice.
Don't listen to your teachers. Write like you talk.